NTA Monitor

Latest News

Living with threats

1st August 2010 Back in 2004, Bill Gates predicted that spam would be a thing of the past within two years. As we all know now, and quite a lot of people predicted at the time, far from being a solved problem, the volume of spam has continued to increase. Read More

Web application security goes from bad to worse in many sectors

27th July 2010 NTA Monitor's 2010 Annual Web Application Security Report analysed the data gathered from web application security tests performed for a wide range of industry sectors over a 12-month period... Read More

IT Managers get to grips with Internet security issues

4th May 2010 According to NTA Monitor's 2010 Annual Security Report, the average number of Internet security vulnerabilities afflicting organisations has fallen.. Read More

Responsible Patching

1st January 2010 Microsoft's response to the "zero day" exploit that was used in the cyber attacks against Google shows that software vendors still have a lot to learn when it comes to responding to vulnerabilities. Read More

Nortel VPN Router Malformed Packet DoS Vulnerability

Overview

NTA Monitor have discovered a denial of service (DoS) vulnerability in the Nortel VPN Router products (which were previously known as Nortel Contivity) while performing a VPN security test for a customer.

We believe that this is a serious vulnerability, because a single malformed IKE packet causes the VPN router to crash. Also it is not normally possible to prevent the malformed packet from reaching the router.

Vulnerability Details

The vulnerability is triggered by sending a single IPsec IKE packet with a malformed ISAKMP header. On receipt of this malformed packet, the VPN router will crash immediately. The crash occurs every time such a malformed packet is sent.

Sometimes the affected VPN router will automatically reboot (which takes about five minutes), but sometimes it will stay down indefinitely and require manual intervention to restart it. In tests, the VPN router automatically rebooted around 80% of the time, and needed to be manually reset on the remaining 20%.

The VPN router does not log the malformed packet, even if the logging level is turned up to maximum. This is probably because the packet causes the router to crash before it has a chance to log it.

It is not normally possible to block public inbound access to the IKE service on the VPN router, because it is required for remote access IPsec operation. As IKE uses the UDP transport protocol, the attacker may forge the packet's source IP address to avoid identification, or to prevent the victim from blocking the traffic with ingress filtering. In addition, current IDS/IPS systems will probably not be able to detect the attack, because the malformed packet looks very similar to a normal IKE packet.

It is possible for attackers to detect and fingerprint Nortel VPN routers using the IKE fingerprinting techniques that we have previously published in VPN security white papers. Therefore users should not assume that their VPN router is invisible just because it's not published in the DNS and is not running any TCP services.

We are not planning to release the precise details of the malformed packet, or the proof-of-concept exploit code due to the danger of an exploit being released before the majority of the Nortel VPN users have upgraded to the fixed version.

Affected Versions

The issues affects Nortel VPN router models 1010, 1050, 1100, 600, 1600, 1700, 2600, 2700, 4500, 4600 and 5000. We believe that all current software versions on the affected models are vulnerable.

Solution

Upgrade to software version V5.05_200 or later. Nortel customers with a valid login may obtain the new software from the Nortel technical support web site:

http://www130.nortelnetworks.com/cgi-bin/eserv/cs/main.jsp

Patches for earlier software releases 4.76, 4.85, 4.90 and 5.00 are expected to be available within a few weeks.

Timeline

The vulnerability was first discovered on 3rd March 2005, and was immediately reported to the customer and Nortel Networks security team. Nortel reproduced the issue, and developed a fix. The fixed version for the latest software was released on 27th May 2005.

References

CVE-2005-1802

Other Information

We would like to thank Nortel Networks for responding promptly to this issue, and producing a software fix to address it.

This advisory was first released on 3rd May 2005.